Is It Ethical to Eat Abandoned Food in a Restaurant? Insights from Nathan Scates

Ever found yourself at a restaurant, where the customers from a nearby table leave and they left untouched food on their table? You might be tempted to eat it, considering it as free food. However, the ethical and legal implications of doing so can be significant. This issue gained national attention with the case of Former Security Officer Nathan A. Scates, who learned the hard way that taking advantage of abandoned food can lead to legal troubles and a cautionary tale for aspiring 'table-scrap thieves.'

The Ethical Dilemma: Public Health and Theft

When considering whether it is ethical to eat abandoned food, there are several factors to take into account, including public health and the ethical implications of theft. Many potential health hazards can arise from consuming food left by others. The customers may have communicable diseases or other health concerns that render the food unsafe to eat. Moreover, the food was likely paid for by the customers, and taking it without permission constitutes theft.

Health Risks: While the food may appear untouched and seemingly safe, food can spoil quickly, and discarded food might attract pests or other contaminants. Additionally, there is no guarantee that the food has been stored and handled safely, which could pose significant health risks.

Nathan Scates: A Cautionary Tale

Nathan A. Scates, a firearms-qualified security officer, faced a harrowing experience when he mistook abandoned food for a free meal. His story serves as a stark reminder of the potential dangers and legal consequences of taking abandoned food in a restaurant.

Incident Overview

Scates was on a break from his demanding duties as a security officer in Portland, Oregon, where he needed a moment to unwind. Despite his job involving hollering racial slurs at Muslim individuals and assaulting Latina women, Scates found solace in the wine country. After drinking a couple of Long Island iced teas and his senses blurring, he spotted an enticing piece of meat on what he believed was an abandoned plate. Upon snatching the meat and stuffing it into his mouth, he realized the plate was not empty, and the food had an owner who was none too pleased about the stolen meal.

The irate group of people followed Scates, their displeasure evident. In his attempt to explain the unfortunate misunderstanding, Scates tried to wave off their anger with his hands, but his mouth was still stuffed with the stolen food, leading to an incoherent and slobbery explanation. Frustrated, the mob urged him to show that he was a good guy. In a mad dash, Scates pulled out his gun and fired multiple shots into the ground, successfully scaring off the crowd.

Legal Consequences and Moral Lessons

Scates' actions, however, led to dire legal and moral consequences. His concealed carry permit was revoked, and he was charged with multiple counts of assault and bias crimes. Furthermore, the bullets fired into the concrete carelessly scattered fragments and debris, potentially harming innocent bystanders. As a result, he faced prison time.

This tragic story highlights the importance of adhering to basic etiquette and ethical standards. Scates learned the hard way that the consequences of such actions can outweigh any perceived benefits of securing a "free" meal. Legal repercussions aside, his story serves as a reminder to respect the property and health concerns of others.

Conclusion: Leaving Abandoned Food Alone

No matter how abandoned the food seems or how tasty it may look, there are better choices than stealing it. Not only is it an ethical violation, but the potential health risks and legal consequences far outweigh any perceived benefits. Instead of attempting to justify taking abandoned food, it is essential to let it alone and find other ways to satisfy your hunger ethically.

Key Takeaways

Ethical and health-related reasons for not eating abandoned food. The legal consequences of taking abandoned food in public spaces. Learning from Nathan Scates' experience to avoid similar situations. The importance of respecting public property and health concerns.

If you find yourself in a similar situation, remember the lessons from Nathan Scates and err on the side of caution and honesty. Your health and the law may thank you for it.