The Best Fish Fry in Milwaukee: A Guide for Food Lovers

Milwaukee, the charming city on the shores of Lake Michigan, is home to a vibrant culinary scene, and perhaps none is more beloved than the iconic fish fry. Whether you're a seasoned local or a visiting foodie, here’s a guide to the best fish frys in Milwaukee, including some personal picks and insider tips.

Overviews and Personal Picks

When it comes to choosing the best fish fry in Milwaukee, it can be a daunting task. However, I must confess that my most cherished experience has been at Serb Hall, a beloved establishment that offers a variety of options, including a traditional battered and fried version and a Serbian style baked in a tomato sauce. Both versions are highly recommended.

Hotspots to Watch

Another remarkable option is Carls on Loomis, a catering place that serves a remarkable fish fry from October to May. If you're fortunate, you can catch this exceptional restaurant be open to the public during these months. While I haven't visited them in recent years, they gained a reputation for their excellence.

Near the airport on Layton Ave, the Packing House is highly regarded. Known for its fresh cod, many believe that cod makes the perfect fish for a traditional Milwaukee fish fry. Despite knowing several restaurants that offer excellent fish frys, including Red Robin, it's worth noting that not all these restaurants are open year-round.

Top Recommendations

In Milwaukee, you can find a great fish fry almost any time you want one. However, here are my top three picks, based not only on my personal experiences but also the collective feedback from customers:

Address: 5101 W. Oklahoma Ave., 414 545-6030

Address: 1872 N. Commerce St., 414 273-8300

Address: 900 E. Layton Ave., 414 483-5054

These establishments are recognized as top choices, but there are countless other excellent options available, including smaller, more local restaurants that may not be as prominent but still offer a fantastic fish fry.

Additional Tips and Insights

Whether you prefer a traditional battered and fried fish, a Serbian style bake, or any variation of cod, Milwaukee has something to please every taste. Fish fries are a longstanding tradition in Milwaukee, with many restaurants offering them on Fridays. However, churches and community centers like Divino’s Wine Dine provide alternative options throughout the week.

While it's easy to fall into the trap of naming just one best restaurant, it's important to recognize that Milwaukee's fish fry scene is diverse, with many restaurants offering unique and delicious options. Whether you're visiting for business, pleasure, or just to try something new, be sure to include a Milwaukee-style fish fry on your culinary to-do list.

Enjoy your culinary adventure in Milwaukee and the fantastic fish frys that await you!