The Origins of the Ice Cream Sundae: A Sweet Debate

Ice cream sundaes are a beloved dessert all around the world. However, the origins of this sweet treat are shrouded in a variety of stories and historical debates. Let's explore where and when the ice cream sundae first appeared and the various claims from different towns and events.

Debates and Theories

The question of where the ice cream sundae originated is one that sparks debate among historians and food enthusiasts. One of the most plausible origins is traced to soda fountains in the early 20th century. During this time, many towns had local councils led by strict, often puritanical “Christians” who banned the sale of alcohol on Sundays. To cater to this, soda fountains would change their menu to only serve non-alcoholic drinks, including ice cream sodas. On Sundays, they would omit the soda water and instead top ice cream with flavored syrup, whipped cream, and a cherry, thus creating the modern sundae.

Early Origins: Chester Platt's Claim

Another claim comes from Chester Platt, the owner of the Platt Colt's Drugstore in 1893. According to this story, Platt prepared a dish of vanilla ice cream for the Reverend John Scott on a Sunday. Platt added a touch of cherry syrup and a candied cherry to the ice cream. Reverend Scott, in his own inspired moment, named the dish after the day: the ice cream sundae.

Two Rivers, Wisconsin: The Accidental Creation

An accidental creation story is attributed to Two Rivers, Wisconsin. Druggist Edward Berners (1863-1939) owned Ed Berners' Ice Cream Parlor. In 1881, a customer requested a vanilla ice cream sundae, but the clerk forgot to add the syrup. The customer liked how the ice cream tasted on its own and requested more. The accidental creation of the ice cream sundae in Two Rivers is a popular local tale and has been embraced by the town.

Other Claims and Controversies

Various localities have claimed to be the birthplace of the ice cream sundae, including Plainfield, Illinois; New Orleans, Louisiana; Cleveland, Ohio; and New York City. Among these, Two Rivers, Wisconsin and Ithaca, New York, have the biggest rivalry. According to sources, the ice cream sundae's origin story can vary widely depending on which town you ask.

While all of these stories offer interesting historical details, the official origin of the ice cream sundae remains up for debate. Each town has its own anecdote and local pride, contributing to the rich tapestry of dessert history.

Conclusion

The ice cream sundae is a beloved dessert that has a fascinating history. Whether it was created deliberately in a drugstore or by accident in a small Wisconsin town, the sundae has captured the hearts of ice cream lovers everywhere. Regardless of its exact origins, the ice cream sundae continues to be a popular treat, celebrated in many ways, from formal dining rooms to casual backyard picnics.